With regard to access to information and privacy coordinators and the concerns raised by the Information Commissioner that government departments are wrongly withholding records, including statistics, on the grounds that they are exempt from disclosure because they count as advice to ministers: (a) what is each government institution doing, if anything, to ensure that they are not abusing this exemption when processing requests; (b) since 2016, has the government
disciplined any institution's access to information and privacy coordinators or employees for
abusing this exemption or otherwise wrongfully withholding information, and, if so, what are the
details, including the dates and incident summaries, of each instance; and (c) broken down by each
institution governed by the Access to Information Act and the Privacy Act, will the institutions abide by the
Information Commissioner's recommendations and not abuse the advice to ministers exemption,
beginning immediately, and, if not, why not?